8 October 2026 · Copy for your two new Lucky ads, the ones that say he sold out in a week and is now back in stock. All five texts say the same thing, that Lucky sold out in a week and is back, each written a different way, so we can see which way of telling it works best. Every line sticks to what happened: a week, nothing more. Edit anything straight on the page, mark each line approved or rejected, then press Send.
How to review: Anything with a pencil is editable, just click and type over it. Mark each one
Approve or Reject.
Your edits and choices save to this page automatically and Casey can see them, so you can close it and come back whenever you like.
When you are done, press Send to Casey at the bottom of the page. That tells Casey you have finished. You do not need to email anything, your marks and edits are saved on this page and Casey can already see them.
Is this restock a limited batch? We have kept every line to what happened: he sold out in a week and is back. If this batch is smaller or one-off, tell us and we can say so honestly. Otherwise we will leave any "limited" wording out.
Lucky the Black Cat, back in stock2 images · 5 main texts · 5 headlines
Cold UK audiences in the Bag Tags campaign. Your existing customers are left out of this campaign, so most people seeing it will be new to you.
Sends to /products/lucky-the-black-cat-bag-tag
Lucky sold out in a week, and your two new pictures say so. Every text below keeps to that: a week, no bigger claims. The new thing we are testing is how the story is told. One text opens on the sell-out, one on Lucky himself, one on "back in stock", one keeps it to two lines, and one tells how he is made. Meta shows each text to different people, so after a couple of weeks we will know which way to write future restocks.
Which writing structure each text uses, and what it tells us
Proof firstOpens with "Sold out in a week." A win tells us the sell-out itself is the hook, so lead with it on every future restock.
Character introductionOpens with "Meet Lucky." like the rest of the Bag Tag Buddies, with the sell-out as supporting proof. A win tells us the character still does the selling.
Restock firstOpens with "Lucky is back in stock." A win tells us "he's back" pulls harder than "he sold out", so more people already know him than we thought.
Short copyTwo lines and nothing else, letting the picture do the work. If it wins, people want less reading on these ads.
StoryMade by hand, gone in a week, back again. A win tells us the handmade story behind the restock adds something on top of the sell-out.
Lucky's current ad, for reference
Your two new ads use this picture of Lucky, with "sold out in a week, now back in stock" as the text on it instead. Every text below works on both.
Primary Text
P1 · Sold out in a week Testing: writing structureStructure: Proof firstEditedRevised since your edit
Sold out in a week.
Lucky is back. 🖤
When we launched our black cat Bag Tag Buddy, he sold out in seven days.
He's now back in stock.
He's hand felted from organic wool by our skilled artisans, so no two Luckys are quite the same.
Tie him on and he'll turn heads wherever you go.
We have revised this line since you edited it.
P2 · Meet Lucky Testing: writing structureStructure: Character introductionEditedRevised since your edit
Meet Lucky. 🖤
He's a black cat in a bright red scarf with gleaming amber eyes, and the first time round he sold out in a week.
Now he's back.
Each Lucky is hand felted from organic wool by our skilled artisans, so yours will be genuinely unique.
Tie him on and see why he went so quickly.
We have revised this line since you edited it.
P3 · He's back Testing: writing structureStructure: Restock firstEditedRevised since your edit
Lucky is back in stock. 🖤
Our black cat Bag Tag Buddy sold out in a week the first time round, and now he's back.
He's hand felted from organic wool by our skilled artisans and arrives in his own organic cotton gift bag, ready to give.
One for the cat lover in your life, or one for you.
We have revised this line since you edited it.
P4 · Two lines Testing: writing structureStructure: Short copyEditedRevised since your edit
Sold out in a week.
Back in stock now. 🖤
Lucky, our hand felted black cat Bag Tag Buddy, is ready to tie on.
We have revised this line since you edited it.
P5 · Felted by hand, gone in a week Testing: writing structureStructure: StoryEditedRevised since your edit
Felted by hand, gone in a week. 🧶
Every Lucky is made by our skilled artisans from organic wool, each one by hand, so the first batch didn't last long.
He's back now: black cat, bright red scarf and a bit of attitude.
Tie him onto your bag, or give him to someone who's always loved a black cat.
We have revised this line since you edited it.
Headlines
H1Sold Out in a Week. Now Back.Edited
the sell-out and the restock together
We have revised this line since you edited it.
H2Lucky Is Back in StockEdited
the plain news
We have revised this line since you edited it.
H3The Black Cat That Sold Out in a WeekEdited
for people who have never heard of him
We have revised this line since you edited it.
H4Missed Lucky? He's BackEdited
for people who missed him the first time
We have revised this line since you edited it.
H5Hand Felted Lucky, Back in StockEdited
handmade, and available
We have revised this line since you edited it.
Nothing marked yet
Saved
Send your picks to Casey
Everything below has been copied to your clipboard. Paste it into a reply to Casey, or press Open email and paste it there.